While engaging with policy networks can be daunting due to the unpredictability of outcomes and ethical concerns, researchers can manage these risks by clarifying their values and ethics beforehand. By actively reflecting on their approach and staying aware of ethical boundaries during interactions, researchers can navigate the complexities of policy engagement while maintaining their integrity and avoiding potential ethical pitfalls.
The following video is a recording of a live webinar in which Professor Eric Jensen presents the findings of their research on the ethics of engagement and impact. If you want to learn more about the essentials of ethical research impact, consider enrolling in this course.
Interview with Robert McMorran
In this interview, Robert McMorran, a social researcher with the Scottish Government, focuses on managing risks when engaging with policy networks. He discusses strategies for establishing effective feedback mechanisms with policy professionals, ensuring research remains relevant and impactful. McMorran emphasises the importance of building long-term relationships and networks, attending relevant events, and taking opportunities to present and discuss research with policymakers. He advises on maintaining contact with policy figures throughout and beyond the lifespan of research projects, highlighting the benefits of such engagements for both researchers and policy outcomes.
Practise Your Mindfulness Muscle
Mindfulness is essential for managing risks in policy engagement. To systematically address these risks, incorporate practical steps into your impact plan. Identify potential risks for each impact and engagement activity, such as unintended consequences or exacerbating conflicts.
-
Assess risks. Evaluate the risks of unintended consequences from policy options based on your research and seek input from those affected, using your 3i analysis.
-
Evaluate engagement activities. Gather feedback from stakeholders or experienced colleagues to assess risks in your planned activities.
-
Monitor and evaluate. Continuously monitor your engagement and impact to identify early issues and minimise future risks. Adapt your plans as circumstances change.
While ethics approval is necessary only for research with human subjects, consulting ethics experts can be valuable when dealing with controversial topics or vulnerable groups.